Austin Gallery

Art Supplies

5 Best Oil Pastels of 2026 — Artist Grade, Ranked

Sennelier are so soft they behave like paint; Holbein hold an edge. We ranked five oil pastel sets on binder softness, pigment load, and the gap between artist and student grade.

By Justin ParkUpdated August 29, 202610 min readHow we research

★ Our Top Pick

Sennelier Oil Pastels, Introductory Set of 24

Sennelier Oil Pastels, Introductory Set of 24

The softest, most pigmented stick made. Blends under a finger like oil paint.

~$69rated 4.8/5 in our review

Not sure yet? Compare all 5 picks below ↓

Oil pastels have a reputation problem, and it comes almost entirely from the ones handed out in primary schools. Student-grade oil pastels are wax-heavy, low in pigment, and skate over the paper leaving a shiny, unblendable film. Artist-grade oil pastels are a different material: soft, densely pigmented sticks that smear, layer, and blend closer to oil paint than to crayon.

The variable that separates them is binder softness. Softer binders carry more pigment and blend under a finger; harder binders hold an edge and let you draw a line. Sennelier sits at the extreme soft end — almost greasy — while Holbein sits firmer and more controllable.

We ranked five sets on softness, pigment load, and lightfastness. Every link goes to Amazon with our affiliate tag; we earn a small commission at no cost to you.

Best OverallOur Pick

Grade

Artist

Binder

Very soft, mineral wax and oil

Count

24 colours

Lightfastness

Good to excellent across most of the range

Best For

Painterly blending, impasto, full coverage

Pros

  • The softest, most pigment-dense oil pastel available
  • Blends under a finger like wet paint
  • Full opaque coverage in a single pass
  • Layers thickly for genuine impasto texture
  • Open stock available for replacing heavily used colours

Cons

  • Very soft — crumbles, and fine detail is impossible
  • Never dries; work must be framed under glass with a spacer
  • Expensive per stick
  • Messy in warm hands

Sennelier oil pastels were developed at Picasso's request for a stick that behaved like paint, and that origin still describes them exactly. The binder is soft to the point of greasiness, which is precisely what lets the pigment move under a finger or a blending stump.

Why softness is the whole spec: oil pastel work is built by smearing and layering, not by hatching. A hard stick deposits colour that sits on the surface and refuses to merge; a Sennelier melts into the layer beneath it, which is what makes blended passages possible at all.

Coverage is the other advantage. One pass of a Sennelier is opaque, so you spend layers on colour decisions rather than on building density — which matters because oil pastel accepts only a handful of layers before the surface goes slick and rejects more.

Plan for framing before you start. Oil pastel never fully cures. Finished work needs glazing with a spacer or a mat deep enough to keep the glass off the surface, or the pastel will transfer onto it. See our framing masterclass for the spacer method.

Our Pick

The oil pastel the medium is judged by — originally made for Picasso, and still the softest, most pigment-dense stick available. Sennelier blend under a finger like oil paint and cover in a single pass.

Buy Sennelier if you want oil pastel to behave like paint: heavy blending, thick impasto passages, and full coverage. The 24-set is the right entry, covering the wheel without the price of the larger boxes.

What we don't like

They are extremely soft, close to greasy, which means crumbling, dirty fingers, and no fine detail — these are not drawing sticks. They never dry, so finished work must be framed under glass with a spacer, and they're expensive per stick.

Best for ControlAlso Great

Grade

Artist

Binder

Firm to medium

Count

15 colours

Lightfastness

High across the range

Best For

Drawing and painting combined, layered work

Pros

  • Firm enough to hold an edge and draw a real line
  • Accepts more layers before the surface goes slick
  • Cleaner in the hand than very soft brands
  • High lightfastness across the range
  • Excellent pigment density for the firmness

Cons

  • Blends less freely — needs a stump, finger, or solvent
  • 15 colours is a small working set
  • Firmness means less impasto texture

Holbein is the answer for anyone who found Sennelier uncontrollable. The firmer binder gives up some blending in exchange for something Sennelier genuinely cannot do: hold an edge.

Layer capacity is the underrated advantage: a firmer stick deposits a thinner film, so the surface stays receptive through more passes. If your process builds colour gradually rather than in one heavy application, that extra headroom matters more than raw blendability.
Blending needs help. Where a Sennelier moves under a bare finger, Holbein usually wants a paper stump, a silicone shaper, or a touch of odourless mineral spirits on a brush. Solvent turns oil pastel into something very close to oil paint — worth knowing before you decide these are too stiff.

Also Great

Artist-grade pigment in a firmer binder. Holbein hold an edge well enough to draw with, layer without going slick as fast as Sennelier, and stay clean in the hand — the choice when the work has drawing in it.

Buy Holbein if you want oil pastel that can render an edge as well as a blended field. Mixed drawing-and-painting approaches suit these far better than Sennelier's near-liquid softness.

What we don't like

They don't blend as freely as Sennelier and need more encouragement — a stump, a fingertip, or a little solvent. A 15-colour set is small, so you'll be mixing on the surface more than you might expect.

Best Value Artist Set

Grade

Student

Binder

Firm to medium

Count

36 colours

Lightfastness

Not fully documented

Best For

Learning, studies, classroom use

Pros

  • 36 colours at the price of a small artist set
  • Genuine oil pastel behaviour, not a wax crayon
  • Cheap enough to work freely and waste sticks
  • Firm binder is forgiving for beginners

Cons

  • Lower pigment load needs more passes for coverage
  • Lightfastness not documented — unsuitable for sale work
  • Blends less readily than artist-grade

The gap between student and artist oil pastel is pigment load, and it shows up as passes-to-coverage. That matters more in this medium than most, because oil pastel accepts only a handful of layers before the surface stops taking colour.

Still a genuine oil pastel: the important distinction is that these behave like the real material — they smear, layer, and blend. Craft-store "oil pastels" at similar prices are wax crayons that do none of that, and they teach the wrong technique.

Holbein's student line, and the best value in the category. Meaningfully below the Artists' range on pigment load, but far above the craft-grade sticks it sits near in price — and 36 colours for the cost of a small artist set.

Buy the Academic set if you're learning oil pastel, working through studies, or want broad colour range without artist-grade pricing. It's also the sensible set for classroom and workshop use.

What we don't like

Lower pigment load means more passes for full coverage, which eats into oil pastel's limited layer capacity. Lightfastness is not documented to the standard of the Artists' range, so this isn't a set for work you intend to sell.

Best Small Starter

Grade

Artist

Binder

Very soft

Count

6 colours

Lightfastness

Good to excellent

Best For

Trying Sennelier, travel, supplementing a firmer set

Pros

  • Real artist-grade Sennelier at a trivial price
  • The cheapest honest test of whether soft pastels suit you
  • Useful as soft accents alongside a firmer main set
  • Compact for travel

Cons

  • Six colours is a sampler, not a working palette
  • Same crumbling and mess as the full set

Softness is polarizing, and that's the whole reason this set exists. Some painters find Sennelier's near-greasy handling liberating; others find it uncontrollable and go straight back to a firmer brand. Sixteen dollars answers the question.

A genuinely useful mixed approach: keep a firm set as the working palette and a few Sennelier sticks for the passages that need to blend hard. Firm for structure, soft for the fields — you don't have to pick a side.

Six real Sennelier sticks for the price of a sandwich and a coffee. The right way to find out whether the extreme softness suits you before committing to a full set.

Buy this to test Sennelier's handling before spending on the 24 or 48. It's also a good travel set, and a cheap way to add a few genuinely soft sticks to a firmer Holbein-based palette.

What we don't like

Six colours is a sampler, not a palette — you'll be mixing constantly on the surface, which oil pastel does less gracefully than paint. Same softness caveats as the larger set.

Austin Art Insider

Free weekly guide to galleries, exhibitions & collecting in Austin.

Best Budget

Grade

Student

Binder

Firm, waxy

Count

50 colours

Lightfastness

Not documented

Best For

Children, classrooms, colour studies

Pros

  • Extremely cheap for 50 colours
  • Non-toxic and appropriate for children
  • Firm sticks resist breakage
  • Fine for large studies where cost per stick matters

Cons

  • Low pigment load — colours read chalky
  • Waxy binder blends poorly
  • No lightfastness data; not for sale work

This is the set most people mean when they say they don't like oil pastels — and it's worth being clear that the medium is not the problem. Pentel does exactly what it promises at its price, but the waxy binder and modest pigment load produce the shiny, unblendable surface that gives oil pastel its reputation.

Where it genuinely earns a place: children, classrooms, and large-scale colour studies where you want to work without counting the cost of each stick. Just don't judge the medium by it.

Fifty colours for under ten dollars. Firmly student-grade and no substitute for artist sticks, but honest about what it is — and the right set for children, classrooms, and figuring out whether you like the medium at all.

Buy Pentel for kids, classrooms, and no-stakes experimenting. It's also useful for large colour studies where you'd rather not burn through expensive sticks.

What we don't like

Low pigment load and a hard, waxy binder — blending is limited and colours look chalky next to artist grade. No lightfastness data, so nothing made with these should be sold as lasting work.

How we
chose

This is a research-desk guide. We compared published pigment and binder information from each manufacturer against what oil-pastel painters consistently report in long-run use — particularly around blending behaviour and whether finished work stays put. Four criteria:

  • Binder softness. The property that decides everything else. Soft sticks blend and layer like paint but crumble and can't hold a line; firm sticks draw cleanly but resist blending.
  • Pigment load. How much colour a single pass lays down. Low-pigment sticks need many layers, and oil pastel doesn't take many layers before the surface goes slick and stops accepting more.
  • Lightfastness. Whether the manufacturer publishes ratings, and how much of the range is safe for work intended for sale.
  • Whether the work stays put. Oil pastel never fully dries. We noted how much each set smudges after the fact and what that means for framing and storage.

Share this guide

Share

Common Questions

Frequently Asked Questions

Have art
to sell?

Austin Gallery specializes in selling inherited art, estate collections, and fine art with zero upfront fees. Get a free evaluation today.