Key Takeaways
- Best Overall (pro): Golden Heavy Body Acrylics — buttery body, highest pigment load we tested, lightfastness rating I across the line.
- Best for Beginners: Liquitex BASICS — student-grade quality at a price you can actually paint with.
- Best Fluid: Golden Fluid Acrylics — same pigment load as Heavy Body but pours and drips.
- Best Mid-Range Pro: Winsor & Newton Galeria — close to artist-grade for half the price.
- Skip: Anything not labeled with a lightfastness rating. If they don't print it, it's bad.
Cheap acrylic paint dries chalky, fades within five years, and tells you the price every time you load the brush. Good acrylic paint glides, holds true color a decade later, and rewards every brushstroke with a different texture.
In This Article
- What to Look For in Acrylic Paint
- Quick Comparison: All 12 Acrylic Lines at a Glance
- Detailed Reviews
- Best Overall (Pro): Golden Heavy Body Acrylics
- Golden Heavy Body Acrylics Set
- Best for Beginners: Liquitex BASICS
- Liquitex BASICS Acrylic Paint Set
- Best Fluid: Golden Fluid Acrylics
- Golden Fluid Acrylics Set
- Best Mid-Range Pro: Winsor & Newton Galeria
- Winsor & Newton Galeria Acrylics
- Premium Artist Picks: Holbein, Sennelier, Amsterdam
- Specialty / Slow-Drying: Chroma Atelier Interactive
- Chroma Atelier Interactive Acrylics
- Budget / Volume / Schools: Blickrylic + Arteza
- Matisse Flow Formula
- How to Build a Pro Palette (Without Buying 60 Tubes)
- Frequently Asked Questions
- What's the difference between heavy body and soft body acrylics?
- Are student-grade acrylics safe to mix with pro paints?
- Why do my acrylics dry too fast?
- Are acrylic paints lightfast for archival work?
- Can I use acrylic paint for outdoor murals?
- What's the best surface to paint acrylic on?
- Which acrylic medium should I buy first?
- The Bottom Line
We worked with twelve acrylic lines over nine months — daily — and ranked them by pigment load, lightfastness, body, and how they actually behave under a brush in a working studio. Here's what made the cut.
What to Look For in Acrylic Paint
Three things separate professional acrylics from junk:
- Pigment load. Premium acrylics pack more pigment per ml. You can see it: a tube of Golden Heavy Body Cadmium Red squeezes out concentrated, rich, and a little goes a long way. A tube of cheap acrylic squeezes out watery, you use 3x as much, and the color is duller.
- Lightfastness rating. ASTM (American Society for Testing and Materials) classifies pigments I (excellent — 100+ years), II (very good — 50-100 years), III (fair — fades), IV (poor — fades fast), V (very poor). Good brands print the rating on every tube. Skip anything that doesn't.
- Body / consistency. Heavy body holds brushstrokes (impasto), fluid pours, soft body is between. Most painters want at least one heavy body line plus one fluid for variety.
Price is the worst signal. A $25 tube of Holbein is fantastic; a $25 tube of certain Amazon-only brands is junk. Brand reputation is the better signal. Trust Golden, Liquitex, Winsor & Newton, Sennelier, Holbein, Matisse, and Amsterdam.
$25
A tube of Holbein is fantastic; a $25 tube of certain Amazon-only brands is junk
Quick Comparison: All 12 Acrylic Lines at a Glance
| Brand | Body | Pigment Load | Lightfastness | Best For | Price/22ml |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Golden Heavy Body | Heavy | Highest | I (most colors) | Pro impasto, lasting work | $11–18 |
| Liquitex Heavy Body | Heavy | High | I | Pro standard, mid-budget | $9–14 |
| Winsor & Newton Galeria | Soft body | Mid-high | I-II | Pro who paints volume | $6–9 |
| Golden Fluid | Fluid | Highest | I | Pours, glazes, mixed media | $11–18 |
| Liquitex BASICS | Soft body | Mid | II-III | Beginners, large works | $4–6 |
| Amsterdam Standard | Soft body | Mid-high | I-II | European pros, value | $6–10 |
| Blickrylic Student | Soft body | Mid | II-III | Schools, classrooms | $4–8 |
| Matisse Flow Formula | Fluid | High | I | Australian color standard | $9–14 |
| Chroma Atelier Interactive | Soft body | High | I | Slow-drying / blend control | $8–12 |
| Arteza 60-Color Set | Soft body | Low-mid | II-III | Beginners, color exploration | $1–2 (set price) |
| Sennelier Abstract | Heavy | High | I | Pro French line | $10–16 |
| Holbein Heavy Body | Heavy | Highest | I | Pro, finest pigment grind | $11–22 |
Detailed Reviews
Best Overall (Pro): Golden Heavy Body Acrylics
Golden Heavy Body Acrylics Set
$11–18 per 22ml tube; sets from $40
Highest pigment load of any acrylic we tested. Lightfastness I across most of the line. Buttery body that holds brushstrokes without medium. The benchmark.
View on Amazon
Check Current PriceGolden is the standard against which other heavy body acrylics are measured. The pigment load is genuinely higher than competitors — load up a brush with Golden Cadmium Yellow and one with a "premium" student-grade equivalent and the difference in coverage is stark. Lightfastness rating I across most of the line means a Golden painting from 2026 will look the same in 2125.
The body is what painters describe as "buttery" — it holds peaks and brushstrokes without medium, but it's not so stiff that it chunks. Across nine months we used Golden as the control reference for everything else.
Why it wins: Highest pigment load. Most consistent body across colors. Lightfastness across the line.
The catch: Most expensive. $11-18 per 22ml tube. A complete pro palette runs $200+.
Best for Beginners: Liquitex BASICS
Liquitex BASICS Acrylic Paint Set
$4–6 per 75ml tube; 24-color set ~$45
The student-grade line from Liquitex (the same company that makes the pro Heavy Body). Lower pigment load than the pro line, but real lightfastness ratings and clean color. The right starter paint.
View on Amazon
Check Current PriceIf you're starting out, do not buy the cheapest paint you can find on Amazon. Buy Liquitex BASICS instead. It's still affordable ($4-6 per 75ml is fine for student volume) but it's actually professional-quality lite — Liquitex makes pro Heavy Body for 50 years and BASICS is the same DNA at a lower pigment load.
You'll get accurate color, decent lightfastness (II-III), real-feeling body. You'll learn good habits because the paint actually behaves.
Why it wins for beginners: Real brand reputation, real lightfastness, real body — at a price you can actually paint volume with.
The catch: Lower pigment load. Once you know what you're doing, you'll feel the difference vs Heavy Body.
Best Fluid: Golden Fluid Acrylics
Golden Fluid Acrylics Set
$11–18 per 1oz bottle
Same pigment load as Heavy Body, but a flowing consistency that pours, drips, and dries in a smoother film. The pro choice for glazes, mixed media, and pour painting.
View on Amazon
Check Current PriceGolden Fluid is what you reach for when Heavy Body is wrong: glazes, washes, pour painting, mixed media on drawings. Same pigment per ml as Heavy Body — Golden engineers Fluid to keep pigment load at the same level despite the lower viscosity, which is why their Fluid line is in a different league than competitors.
Why it wins for fluid: Pigment load you can't get from any other fluid line.
The catch: Same price as Heavy Body. Buy what you'll use.
Best Mid-Range Pro: Winsor & Newton Galeria
Winsor & Newton Galeria Acrylics
$6–9 per 60ml tube
Galeria is W&N's "studio professional" line — between BASICS-tier student and full Artists' line. Soft body, lightfastness I-II, near-pro pigment load at a price that lets you paint volume.
Austin Art Insider
Free weekly guide to galleries, exhibitions & collecting in Austin.
View on Amazon
Check Current PriceGaleria is the sweet spot. It's a real Winsor & Newton — same brand reputation that comes with their oils — at half the price of full pro acrylic. Most production painters who do volume work use Galeria as their everyday paint and reserve Heavy Body for finished pieces.
The body is softer than Golden Heavy Body but firmer than fluid. Color is honest. Lightfastness is rated and the ratings are accurate (we tested by leaving swatches in a south-facing Austin window for 6 months — the I-II rated colors held up).
Why it wins mid-range: Near-pro quality at a real price.
The catch: Doesn't hold heavy peaks the way Golden Heavy Body does — softer body.
Premium Artist Picks: Holbein, Sennelier, Amsterdam
For painters who already know they want pro paint:
Holbein Heavy Body Acrylics — Japanese brand, finest pigment grind we tested. Some Holbein colors are noticeably different from Golden equivalents (Holbein Quinacridone Magenta is more vivid than Golden's). Worth experimenting with if you're a serious painter looking for color depth.
Sennelier Abstract — French line, packaged in distinctive pouches that don't clog. Pigment load and lightfastness rival Golden. Slightly more "European" color palette (the yellows are different from American brands).
Amsterdam Standard — Royal Talens (Holland). Mid-priced, very high pigment load for the cost, and the line includes interference and metallic colors that other student-tier lines skip.
Any of these three is a defensible upgrade from Liquitex Heavy Body. Try one tube of each before committing to a line.
Specialty / Slow-Drying: Chroma Atelier Interactive
Chroma Atelier Interactive Acrylics
$8–12 per 80ml tube
Re-wettable acrylic. Once the paint is on canvas, mist it with water and you can keep working it like an oil. Bridges acrylic and oil techniques.
View on Amazon
Check Current PriceFor painters trained in oil who want to switch to acrylic without giving up wet-blending: Chroma Atelier Interactive lets you mist the working surface and keep blending for hours. It's the closest acrylic gets to oil paint behavior. The pigment load is high; lightfastness is I. Worth a try if you're an oil painter exploring acrylic.
Budget / Volume / Schools: Blickrylic + Arteza
For classrooms, art schools, and beginners painting volume to learn:
Blickrylic Student Acrylic Paint — Blick's own house brand. Surprisingly good for the price. Real lightfastness ratings. Solid body. The right paint for a teacher equipping a class.
Arteza 60-Color Set — A mountain of color for $50-80. Pigment load is mid; some colors are more honest than others. Great for color exploration / learning. Don't use for finished work you'd sell.
Matisse Flow Formula
Matisse Flow Formula Acrylics is an Australian brand that's harder to find but worth the search. Their colors (especially their unique titanium pigments) are different from American/European acrylics. If you want a color palette that doesn't look like everyone else's, try a tube of Matisse.
How to Build a Pro Palette (Without Buying 60 Tubes)
You can paint anything with 8-10 tubes. Here's the foundational set:
Yellows: Cadmium Yellow Light + Yellow Ochre
Reds: Cadmium Red Light + Quinacridone Magenta + Burnt Sienna
Blues: Ultramarine Blue + Phthalocyanine Blue
Earths: Burnt Umber + Raw Umber
Whites: Titanium White (always have two tubes — you'll use them faster than anything else)
Black: Mars Black or Carbon Black (or skip — mix from Ultramarine + Burnt Umber)
In Golden Heavy Body, this 10-color set runs about $130. In Galeria it runs about $70. In BASICS it runs about $45.
For brushes to use with these paints, see our 11 best paint brushes for acrylic, watercolor, and oil guide.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the difference between heavy body and soft body acrylics?
Heavy body holds brushstrokes — peaks, ridges, impasto. Soft body flows more easily and dries to a smoother film. Heavy body is what most pros use for opaque painting. Soft body is better for layered glazes, smooth surfaces, and large flat areas.
Are student-grade acrylics safe to mix with pro paints?
Yes — all acrylics are chemically compatible. The downside of mixing is the lower-pigment-load student paints can dilute the color of pro paints. Most painters mix when blocking in (use student paint for under-painting) and switch to pro paint for the finishing layers.
Why do my acrylics dry too fast?
Acrylic dries fast by design. To slow it down: use a retarder medium (Liquitex Slow-Dri Medium, Golden Open Medium), keep a wet palette (sponge under parchment paper), or use Chroma Atelier Interactive which is engineered to be re-wettable. Avoid working in dry low-humidity rooms — Austin in August is brutal on acrylic working time.
Are acrylic paints lightfast for archival work?
The pigments are. Modern pro acrylic paints with ASTM I or II ratings will hold color for 50-100+ years under normal display conditions. The acrylic binder is also stable — modern acrylics don't yellow the way old oil paints can. For finished work you intend to sell or hang, only use I or II rated colors.
Modern pro acrylic paints with ASTM I or II ratings will hold color for 50-100+ years under normal display conditions.
Can I use acrylic paint for outdoor murals?
Yes, but use a brand designed for it (Golden makes specific outdoor-rated lines). Standard interior acrylic will hold up several years outdoors but eventually fade and chalk. For permanent outdoor work, professional muralists typically use Nova Color or Golden Sign Painters acrylics.
What's the best surface to paint acrylic on?
Stretched canvas (acrylic-primed) is the standard. Canvas board works for studies. Wood panels are the choice for serious work that needs to last centuries — modern primed birch panels are durable and don't flex. Paper works for studies, especially heavy watercolor paper.
Which acrylic medium should I buy first?
Matte medium. It thins paint without weakening pigment (water dilutes pigment past about 30% water-to-paint), keeps colors brilliant, and acts as a glue when collaging. Learn matte medium first; add specialty mediums (gloss, retarder, gel) later.
It thins paint without weakening pigment (water dilutes pigment past about 30% water-to-paint), keeps colors brilliant, and acts as a glue when collaging.
The Bottom Line
For pro work that lasts: Golden Heavy Body (or Holbein if you want to experiment with different pigments).
For starting out without buying junk: Liquitex BASICS.
For real volume work at sustainable cost: Winsor & Newton Galeria.
For pour painting and glazes: Golden Fluid.
For brushes to pair with these paints, see 11 best paint brushes 2026. For the watercolor side of the studio, see best watercolor paper.




