Austin Gallery
PrintmakingSeptember 17, 202614 min read

The Best Brayers and Block Printing Inks of 2026

Speedball and Essdee rollers in soft and hard rubber, Cranfield Caligo Safe Wash and Speedball inks in water-based, safe-wash oil, and traditional oil: eight verified picks and the two decisions, soft versus hard and water versus oil, that decide how a lino print looks.

By Justin Park · How we research

★ Our Top Pick

Speedball Deluxe Soft Rubber Brayer, 4 in, 40/42 Durometer

Speedball Deluxe Soft Rubber Brayer, 4 in, 40/42 Durometer

40/42 durometer soft rubber on a steel frame. The studio standard.

$24.99rated 4.7/5 in our review

Not sure yet? Compare all 8 picks below ↓

The best brayer for block printing in 2026 is the Speedball Deluxe Soft Rubber Brayer ($25), and the best block printing ink is Cranfield Caligo Safe Wash Black ($16). Together they are $41 and they cover linocut, woodcut, and most relief printing at a level that does not need upgrading. Around them we compared the Speedball and Essdee roller lines in soft and hard rubber, and Cranfield and Speedball inks in water-based, safe-wash oil, and traditional oil, so you can build the right kit for your work rather than the kit in the starter box.

Why the brayer and ink matter more than the block

Printmakers spend their money on presses and carving tools and then ink the block with a $3 roller and craft paint, and the print looks like it. The brayer decides whether the ink film is thin and even; the ink decides whether it transfers fully and dries to a dense, clean color. Get those two right and a hand-burnished lino print on decent paper looks professional. Get them wrong and no press fixes it. The two decisions that matter are soft versus hard rubber (soft for coverage and most work, hard for fine detail) and water-based versus oil-based ink (water for fabric, classrooms, and gel plates; oil for anything you would frame), and each gets its own section below. Every link goes to Amazon with our affiliate tag; we earn a small commission at no cost to you. For the carving side, see our linocut and block printing kits guide; for gel plate monoprinting, our best gel printing plates guide; for presses, our printmaking presses guide.

Best Brayer OverallOur Pick

Width

4 in

Rubber

Soft, 40/42 durometer (listing)

Frame

Heavy duty steel

Best for

Lino, wood, gel plates, most relief work

Brand

Speedball

Pros

  • Steel frame stays true under pressure
  • 40/42 durometer is the right softness for relief and gel
  • The studio and classroom standard
  • Rolls oil and water-based inks equally well

Cons

  • $25, the priciest 4 inch roller here
  • Slow on large blocks
  • Soft rubber attracts lint

A brayer has one job, laying a thin, even film of ink, and the two things that decide how well it does that are the rubber hardness and the frame. The Speedball Deluxe gets both right. The listing states a 40/42 durometer soft rubber roller, which is soft enough to conform to the tiny height variations across a carved block and lay ink into the whole surface, and a heavy duty steel frame that does not twist when you lean on it. Cheap brayers fail at the frame first: plastic arms flex, the roller wobbles, and the ink film goes streaky.

Soft rubber is the right default for relief printing. It follows the block surface and covers fully with fewer passes. Hard rubber, covered below, is the specialist for crisp fine detail where you want ink only on the very top of the block. Most printmakers own one of each and reach for the soft one nine times in ten.

Four inches is the width to start with. It covers a 5 by 7 block in two passes and an 8 by 10 in three, it fits a standard ink slab, and it is the size that the whole Speedball line is built around. For A3 blocks and 12 inch gel plates, a wider roller like the Essdee 30 cm in the comparison table below earns its place as a second brayer. Our linocut and block printing kits guide covers the carving side; this page is about getting ink onto the block.

Our Pick

The brayer to own if you own one. The listing states a 40/42 durometer soft rubber roller on a heavy duty steel frame, which is the combination that lays an even film on lino, wood, and gel plates alike and does not flex or wobble under a firm hand. Four inches covers the blocks most people carve.

Buy it as your first serious brayer for linocut, woodcut, or gel printing, or as the replacement when a plastic-frame roller starts skipping. It is the default in classrooms and studios for a reason.

What we don't like

Four inches is slow on blocks over 8 by 10, and $25 is the highest price here for a 4 inch roller. Soft rubber also picks up debris more readily than hard, so keep the ink slab clean.

Best Block Printing Ink OverallOur Pick

Base

Oil-based, washes up with soap and water (listing)

Size

75 ml tube

Color

Black

Best for

Linocut and woodcut on paper

Brand

Cranfield Colours (UK)

Pros

  • Oil-based depth and open time, water cleanup
  • Dense, even black on lino and wood
  • No solvents in the studio
  • $16 for a tube that lasts

Cons

  • Days to dry, not minutes
  • Not for gel plates
  • Slower turnaround for stacking editions

For decades the choice was binary: water-based inks that dry fast and print flat, or oil-based inks that print beautifully and need solvent cleanup. Cranfield's Caligo Safe Wash is the product that broke that trade. It is a genuine oil-based relief ink, so it rolls out with the long, even tack that lino wants, stays open on the slab long enough to pull a whole edition, and lays down a deep, velvety black. Then it washes off the block, the brayer, and your hands with soap and water.

Why oil-based still matters for relief: the ink film's tack is what transfers a full, even black from the block to the paper under hand pressure or a light press. Water-based inks dry as you work, go patchy on large flats, and often need a press to look their best. Safe Wash gives you the oil result without the turpentine.

The one real trade is drying time. Oil-based inks cure by oxidation over days, so an edition needs a drying rack or interleaving with clean paper. Plan for it, and pull on a press like the ones in our printmaking presses guide or with a baren, and this is the best ink on Amazon for lino on paper. Heavy users should look at the 500 g tin at $50.

Our Pick

The ink that ended the water-versus-oil argument for most home printmakers. Caligo Safe Wash is a true oil-based relief ink, with the depth, open time, and dense black of oil, that cleans up with soap and water. A 75 ml tube is $16 and lasts through a lot of editions.

Buy it for linocut and woodcut on paper if you want rich, professional prints without solvents in the house. It is the ink we would put in a beginner's first order and the one serious printmakers keep coming back to.

What we don't like

Oil-based means slow drying: prints take days to cure fully, not minutes, and stacking them too soon smudges. It is also a poor match for gel plates, where it is hard to clean off the surface.

Best Budget BrayerBudget Pick

Width

4 in

Rubber

Soft rubber

Frame

Pop-in roller, plastic handle

Best for

Gel plates, second color, light lino

Pros

  • $15
  • Roller pops out for cleaning under the tap
  • Same soft rubber as the Deluxe

Cons

  • Lighter frame flexes under heavy pressure
  • Not the one for daily large-block work

The pop-in design is a real feature, not a compromise. The roller lifts out of the frame so you can rinse it under a tap and drop it back in, which matters when you are switching colors on a gel plate every few minutes. That is why it is the brayer we recommend in our best gel printing plates guide.

For lino it works fine on small and medium blocks. The frame is where it gives up ground to the Deluxe: under the kind of pressure a dense A4 woodcut wants, the plastic arms flex and the film goes uneven. If that is your work, spend the extra $10. If not, this is all the brayer you need.

The pop-in roller is also the reason to buy this over the no-name multipacks at similar money: Speedball sells replacement rollers, so when the rubber eventually wears or nicks you replace the roller rather than the tool. Keep the roller ends clean of dried ink, where paint collects and cracks the rubber first.

Budget Pick

The same soft rubber in a lighter frame with a roller that pops out for cleaning. For $10 less than the Deluxe it is the right brayer for gel plates, occasional lino, and anyone who wants a second roller for a second color.

Buy it for gel printing, for a spare roller so you can run two colors without washing between, or as a first brayer if $25 feels like a lot for a roller. It is the brayer in our gel printing plates guide.

What we don't like

The pop-in frame is lighter duty than the Deluxe's steel; lean hard on a big block and it flexes. The roller is the same soft rubber and picks up the same lint.

Best Hard Rubber BrayerDetail Pick

Width

4 in

Rubber

Hard, 80 durometer (listing)

Frame

Heavy duty steel

Best for

Fine-line lino, wood engraving, flat plates

Pros

  • Keeps ink on the surface, out of fine cuts
  • Same steel frame as the Deluxe soft
  • Crisper edges on detailed blocks

Cons

  • Bald spots on uneven blocks
  • Wrong tool for gel plates
  • Second brayer, not first

Every printmaker who carves fine detail eventually discovers why hard brayers exist. A soft roller conforms to the block, which is great for coverage and bad for shallow cuts: it dips into them and inks the floor of a fine hatch, and the print goes muddy. An 80 durometer hard roller stays on the top plane and leaves the cuts clean. Wood engravers work almost exclusively with hard rollers for this reason.

The trade is that hard rubber forgives nothing: the block must be flat, the ink film thin, and the pressure even. For bold, graphic lino it is unnecessary. For detailed work it is the difference between a print that reads and one that does not. Speedball also sells the pop-in hard rubber version for $15 if you want the cheaper frame.

Technique for a hard roller: roll out a thinner film on the slab than you would for soft rubber, listen for a fine hiss rather than a wet slap, and ink the block in several light passes from different directions. The hard rubber will not compensate for a thick film the way soft rubber does, so the discipline is in the slab, not on the block.

Detail Pick

The specialist roller for fine detail. An 80 durometer hard rubber roller on the same steel frame as the Deluxe soft, it rides on the very top of the block and refuses to push ink down into shallow cuts, which is exactly what fine-line linocut and wood engraving want.

Buy it as your second brayer once your carving has fine hatching, thin lines, or shallow textures that a soft roller fills in. Also the right roller for inking a flat plate for gluing or for transfer work.

What we don't like

Hard rubber demands a flatter block and a thinner ink film; on a warped or uneven block it leaves bald patches. It is a poor choice for gel plates, where it skids. Buy soft first.

Austin Art Insider

Free weekly guide to galleries, exhibitions & collecting in Austin.

Best Value Soft BrayerValue Pick

Width

3.94 in (100 mm)

Rubber

Soft, 40 shore EPDM (listing)

Handle

Aluminum

Best for

Lino, budget studios, Essdee kit users

Brand

Essdee (UK)

Pros

  • $15 for 40 shore rubber on a metal handle
  • EPDM rubber resists oil-based ink well
  • Matching 70 shore hard version available

Cons

  • Roller does not remove for cleaning
  • Thinner US support than Speedball

Essdee is the brand behind most of the lino sold in the UK, and its rollers are the value pick in this guide. The listing states a heavy duty EPDM 40 shore soft rubber roller with an aluminum handle, which on paper matches the Speedball Deluxe's softness at Pop-in money. EPDM is a good rubber for oil-based inks; it does not swell or go tacky with solvents the way cheap natural rubber can.

If you want the full Essdee starter, the Essdee Block Printing Essentials Kit at $30 bundles two rollers, three cutters, a handle, and lino, and it is a sensible first box for a beginner. The 70 shore hard roller at $13 is the detail brayer in the same family.

Because the roller is fixed in the frame, cleaning means wiping rather than rinsing the roller alone. Use vegetable oil on a rag for oil-based inks, then soap, and dry it standing on the handle. Treated that way the EPDM rubber lasts years, which at $15 makes it the cheapest cost-per-edition roller in this guide.

Value Pick

The British lino-printing brand's answer to the Speedball Deluxe: a 40 shore EPDM soft rubber roller with a metal handle for $15, which is Pop-in money for Deluxe-class rubber. The 100 mm width is a hair under 4 inches.

Buy it if you want a soft roller with a metal handle at the budget price, or if you already use Essdee lino, cutters, or inks and want the matching roller. It is also sold as a 70 shore hard version for $13.

What we don't like

The roller does not pop out for cleaning, the frame is lighter than the Speedball Deluxe steel, and Essdee's US distribution is thinner than Speedball's if you ever need a replacement roller.

Best Color Ink SetSet Pick

Base

Oil-based, soap-and-water cleanup

Contents

6 x 75 ml tubes

Best for

Reduction prints, color relief work

Brand

Cranfield Colours

Pros

  • The best relief ink, in a color set
  • Colors mix cleanly and stay open
  • About $13 per tube

Cons

  • $79 up front
  • Mixing set, not a full rainbow
  • Days to dry per layer

Color relief printing is where ink quality stops being a preference and starts being a requirement. A reduction print stacks three or four layers of ink on the same sheet, and each layer has to lay evenly over the last without lifting it. Oil-based inks with real tack do that; thin water-based inks struggle, and the difference shows most in flat color fields.

The Safe Wash set gives you six tubes to mix from, with the same soap-and-water cleanup as the black. Cranfield also sells a Soft Shades set of 6 for $87 if muted, pastel palettes are your style. Either way, budget a drying rack and patience between layers.

Mixing tip: keep the set's colors clean by mixing on a glass slab with a palette knife and reserving one brayer per color for a session rather than washing between. The ink's long open time means a mixed pool stays workable for hours, so mix once at the start and print the whole layer from it.

Set Pick

Six 75 ml tubes of the same oil-based, soap-and-water ink, which is the color foundation for reduction prints and multi-block work. At $79 it is about $13 a tube, and it puts a mixing palette in the box.

Buy it if you print in color, especially reduction linocut where you need a palette that mixes cleanly and stays open across several passes. It is also the right set for a printmaker moving up from water-based Speedball colors.

What we don't like

$79 is a real outlay if you mostly print black, the same slow drying applies to every color, and six tubes is a mixing set rather than a rainbow: expect to mix your greens and oranges.

Best Traditional Oil-Based BlackAlso Great

Base

Oil-based (professional relief ink)

Size

8 oz can

Color

Supergraphic Black

Best for

Black editions, large flats, letterpress relief

Brand

Speedball

Pros

  • Maximum black density on flat areas
  • 8 oz for $20 is the cheapest pro black per ounce here
  • Speedball availability everywhere

Cons

  • Oil or solvent cleanup
  • Can skins between sessions
  • Not for gel plates or fabric

If you print a lot of black, the can is the buy. Speedball's Professional Relief Ink line is its traditional oil-based range, and Supergraphic Black is its densest black, formulated for the large flat areas where thin inks go grey and patchy. Eight ounces for $20 is a lot of editions.

The honest difference from the Caligo above is cleanup. This is conventional oil-based ink: vegetable oil on a rag lifts it from the block and brayer, then soap, or a solvent if you prefer. If that is fine in your studio, it prints as well as anything here. If you want water cleanup, Caligo is the answer. Speedball also packages it in a 5 oz tube at $20 for tidier storage.

Because it is stiffer than the Caligo, Supergraphic Black benefits from a minute of working on the slab with a palette knife before rolling, which loosens it to a smooth tack. On a press it needs less pressure than you expect; under a baren it wants a thinner film and patience.

Also Great

Speedball's professional oil-based relief black, in an 8 oz can for $20. Supergraphic Black is the dense, slightly stiff black that experienced printmakers reach for on big flat areas, and the can is the economical way to buy it if you print often.

Buy it if you print black editions regularly, want a traditional oil-based black with maximum density, and are comfortable with solvent or vegetable-oil cleanup. Also the right choice for wood type and letterpress-style relief.

What we don't like

It is a traditional oil-based ink, so cleanup means vegetable oil followed by soap or a solvent, not water. The can skins over between sessions; keep it covered. It is not the beginner's ink.

Best Water-Based Ink SetBeginner Pick

Base

Water soluble (listing)

Contents

6 colors

Surfaces

Fabric and paper (listing)

Cleanup

Water

Best for

Beginners, classrooms, fabric, gel plates

Pros

  • Six colors that work on fabric and paper
  • Water cleanup, fast drying
  • Safe choice for kids and classes

Cons

  • Dries on the slab mid-session
  • Flat areas print less evenly than oil
  • Less depth than Caligo or Supergraphic

Water-based ink is the right answer for a specific set of jobs, and this set covers them. Fabric printing wants an ink that sets without solvents; a classroom wants water cleanup and quick drying; gel plates want an ink that will not gum up the surface. Speedball's six-color fabric-and-paper set does all three, and $33 for six colors is fair.

Where it falls behind is the print itself. Water-based inks dry as you roll, which means the last print in a session gets a thinner, stickier film than the first, and large flat blacks print unevenly under hand pressure. That is the trade for the convenience, and it is why we send anyone printing editions on paper to the Caligo Safe Wash instead. For a single black tube for fabric, Speedball's 2.5 oz fabric block printing black is $12.

For fabric, follow the tube's directions for setting, print on prewashed cotton or linen, and expect a slightly softer hand than screen printing ink. For paper, work fast, keep a mist bottle nearby to slow drying on the slab, and print on smooth papers where the thinner film shows less.

Beginner Pick

The set for classrooms, kids, fabric, and anyone who wants six colors that clean up with water and dry fast. The listing states it works on fabric and paper, which makes it the one set here that prints a tote bag and a greeting card from the same tubes.

Buy it for beginners, school and community studios, printing on fabric, and gel plate work, where fast drying and water cleanup are features rather than compromises.

What we don't like

Water-based inks dry on the slab as you work and go patchy on large flat areas, and the prints lack the depth of the oil-based inks above. Fine for cards and fabric; not for gallery editions.

How we
chose

How we judged brayers and block printing inks:

  • Rubber hardness and frame, stated on the listing. We compared durometer or Shore ratings and frame construction as the makers state them, because those two specs predict how a brayer inks better than anything else.
  • Ink base, honestly labeled. Water-based, safe-wash oil, and traditional oil print and clean up differently. We sorted every ink by what it is, not by how the listing markets it.
  • Owner feedback patterns, not our bench. We did not run these rollers and inks in our shop. We compared the recurring themes in owner feedback (frame flex, seams, drying time, cleanup) against what the specs predict.
  • Brand accountability. Speedball, Cranfield, and Essdee stock replacement rollers and answer email. We say where a no-name multipack leaves you on your own.
  • Verified listings only. Every product, price, and image on this page was checked against the live Amazon catalog at the time of writing. Prices move; treat them as a snapshot.

Share this guide

Share

Common Questions

Frequently Asked Questions

Have art
to sell?

Austin Gallery specializes in selling inherited art, estate collections, and fine art with zero upfront fees. Get a free evaluation today.