Austin Gallery
Sign In
t@austingallery.org

Austin, Texas

Comparisons

Arches vs Fabriano vs Strathmore: Watercolor Paper Compared

Cotton content is the whole argument. We compare the three papers watercolorists actually fight about — on lifting, buckling, sizing, and the price gap between student and professional sheets.

By Justin ParkUpdated August 29, 202611 min readHow we research

★ Our Top Pick

Arches Watercolor Block, 140 lb Cold Press, 9×12 in

Arches Watercolor Block, 140 lb Cold Press, 9×12 in

The reference sheet. Lifts, reworks, and forgives like nothing else. Buy this if you can.

~$41rated 4.8/5 in our review
Check the Arches Block on Amazon →Read the full review ↓

Brightest White

Fabriano Artistico Extra White

~$19 →

Best Value

Strathmore 400 Series Block

~$20 →

Not sure yet? Compare all 4 picks below ↓

Watercolor is the one medium where the paper is not a surface you paint on — it is half the paint system. Pigment sinks in, moves, lifts, and dries differently on every sheet, and a painting that fails on cheap paper often succeeds unchanged on good paper.

The whole comparison reduces to one variable: cotton content. 100% cotton paper absorbs water evenly, lets you lift color back out, and survives repeated scrubbing. Wood-pulp (cellulose) paper is cheaper, brighter white, and does none of those things well.

Arches and Fabriano Artistico are both 100% cotton and are the two sheets professionals argue about. Strathmore is where most people actually start. Here's what separates them, and which one your work needs. Links go to Amazon with our affiliate tag; we earn a small commission at no cost to you.

Best OverallOur Pick
Arches Watercolor Block, 140 lb Cold Press, 9×12 in by Arches

Arches Watercolor Block, 140 lb Cold Press, 9×12 in

Arches~$41
4.8
Check the Arches Block on Amazon →

Available at Amazon

Fibre

100% cotton

Weight

140 lb / 300 gsm

Surface

Cold press

Sizing

Gelatin, internal and external

Format

Block, glued 4 sides

Made

Mould-made, France

Pros

  • The most forgiving sheet made — lifts back to near-white
  • Survives scrubbing, masking fluid, and repeated reworking
  • Block format glued on 4 sides eliminates buckling entirely
  • Consistent sheet-to-sheet; almost no batch variation
  • The reference standard — instruction assumes this behavior

Cons

  • Roughly 3× Strathmore's cost per sheet
  • Slightly warm white mutes very high-key painting
  • Heavy sizing takes adjustment coming from student paper

Arches is the paper the rest of the field is described in relation to. Mould-made from 100% cotton and gelatin-sized both internally and on the surface, it behaves in a way that makes watercolor feel like a controllable medium rather than a gamble.

The sizing is the whole story. Heavy internal sizing keeps pigment sitting in the upper layer of the sheet rather than sinking straight into the fibre. That is what lets you come back with a damp brush and lift a passage almost back to white — the single most useful property watercolor paper can have, and the one cheap paper cannot fake.

The block format matters more than it sounds. Glued on all four edges, the sheet cannot cockle no matter how much water you flood on, and you cut it free only when it's dry and flat. For anyone who has fought a buckling pad, this alone justifies the format.

One honest caveat: Arches sits slightly warm. Against Fabriano Artistico Extra White, high-key washes and the brightest passages read a touch duller. If your work lives at the light end of the value scale, read the Fabriano entry before defaulting here.

Our Pick

The reference sheet the entire medium is measured against. 100% cotton, mould-made, and gelatin-sized throughout — which is why Arches forgives mistakes no other paper forgives. If you can afford it, this is the correct default.

Buy Arches if you work wet-into-wet, lift and rework passages, or use masking fluid. The heavy internal sizing is what makes all three of those survivable. It's also the right choice for finished work you intend to sell or frame.

What we don't like

It is expensive — roughly triple Strathmore per sheet. The surface is slightly warmer and less brilliant white than Fabriano, which mutes very high-key work. And the heavy sizing means pigment sits up longer before sinking, which takes adjustment if you learned on cheap paper.

Check the Arches Block on Amazon →~$41 · Arches
Best for Bright, High-Key WorkAlso Great
Fabriano Artistico Watercolor Block, Extra White, 5×7 in by Fabriano

Fabriano Artistico Watercolor Block, Extra White, 5×7 in

Fabriano~$19
4.7
Check Fabriano Artistico on Amazon →

Available at Amazon

Fibre

100% cotton

Weight

140 lb / 300 gsm

Surface

Cold press

Sizing

Internal and surface sized

Format

Block, glued 4 sides

Made

Mould-made, Italy

Pros

  • Noticeably brighter white — colors read cleaner
  • 100% cotton at a lower entry price than Arches
  • Softer surface takes granulating pigments beautifully
  • Block format prevents buckling
  • Excellent for botanical and high-key subjects

Cons

  • Softer surface wears faster under scrubbing
  • Lifts well, but not quite as cleanly as Arches
  • This block is 5×7 — a study size, not a finished-work size

Fabriano Artistico is the sheet painters move to when Arches' warmth starts bothering them. Same 100% cotton construction, same 140 lb weight, but the Extra White version is genuinely whiter — and on a medium where the paper supplies every highlight, that changes the whole value range of a painting.

Why bright matters in watercolor: you don't paint white, you leave it. Every highlight is bare paper. A brighter sheet raises the top of your value scale, which makes the whole painting read as more luminous without changing a single pigment choice.

The surface is a touch softer than Arches. Granulating pigments settle into it beautifully, which is a real advantage for landscape and texture work. The cost is durability — heavy scrubbing or aggressive masking-fluid lifting will pill this sheet sooner.

Get the size right: this listing is a 5×7 block, which is a study and sketching format. If you want Artistico for finished work, buy the larger blocks or full sheets — the paper is identical, the format is not.

Also Great

The other professional 100% cotton sheet, and brighter than Arches. Extra White is genuinely whiter, so colors read cleaner and high-key work stays luminous. A slightly softer surface that some painters prefer and others find less durable.

Buy Fabriano Artistico if your palette runs bright and light — botanical work, florals, luminous washes — or if Arches' warmth has ever bothered you. Extra White is the version to get; the Traditional White is closer to Arches in tone.

What we don't like

The surface is softer than Arches and shows wear sooner under heavy scrubbing or aggressive masking-fluid removal. Lifting is good but not quite Arches-good. This 5×7 block is a small format — fine for studies, not for finished work.

Check Fabriano Artistico on Amazon →~$19 · Fabriano
Best Value
Strathmore 400 Series Watercolor Block, Cold Press, 9×12 in by Strathmore

Strathmore 400 Series Watercolor Block, Cold Press, 9×12 in

Strathmore~$20
4.6
Check Strathmore 400 on Amazon →

Available at Amazon

Fibre

Cellulose (wood pulp)

Weight

140 lb / 300 gsm

Surface

Cold press

Sizing

Internal

Format

Block, glued 4 sides

Made

USA

Pros

  • Roughly a third the cost per sheet of Arches
  • Block format still prevents buckling
  • Takes a flat wash cleanly for a non-cotton sheet
  • Cheap enough that you paint freely instead of carefully
  • Widely available and consistent

Cons

  • Cellulose, not cotton — limited lifting, permanent first marks
  • Surface pills under scrubbing or heavy reworking
  • Wet-into-wet is harder to control; edges dry hard
  • Not appropriate for archival work intended for sale

There is a real argument for painting on cheap paper, and it isn't only about money. Expensive paper makes people cautious, and caution is fatal in watercolor — the medium rewards committed marks. A block you're willing to fill with failures teaches faster than a block you're saving.

Know exactly what you give up: lifting. On cotton you can pull a passage back toward white; on cellulose the pigment sinks into the fibre and largely stays. Every technique that depends on removing color — softening edges, recovering highlights, correcting a wash — is limited here.

Within the non-cotton class this is the best of them, and the block format is a genuine advantage over the cheaper pads. Just don't diagnose your own skill from results on this paper: many "I can't do wet-into-wet" problems are the sheet, not the painter.

Don't sell originals on this. Wood-pulp paper yellows and becomes brittle over decades. For work a buyer will hang, move to cotton.

The best non-cotton sheet, and the honest place to learn. Cellulose rather than cotton, so it won't lift or rework like Arches — but it takes a wash cleanly, comes in block format, and costs a third as much.

Buy Strathmore 400 if you're learning, practicing volume, or working through studies where the cost per sheet decides how freely you paint. Cheap paper you'll actually use beats expensive paper you're afraid to ruin.

What we don't like

It is not cotton, and no amount of technique changes what that means. Lifting is limited — the first mark is closer to permanent. Heavy reworking pills the surface. Wet-into-wet is less controllable because water sinks in faster and dries harder at the edges.

Check Strathmore 400 on Amazon →~$20 · Strathmore
Best for Detail & Botanical
Arches Aquarelle Watercolor Pad, Hot Press, 140 lb, 9×12 in by Arches

Arches Aquarelle Watercolor Pad, Hot Press, 140 lb, 9×12 in

Arches~$25
4.7
Check Arches Hot Press on Amazon →

Available at Amazon

Fibre

100% cotton

Weight

140 lb / 300 gsm

Surface

Hot press (smooth)

Sizing

Gelatin, internal and external

Format

Pad

Made

Mould-made, France

Pros

  • Smooth surface takes fine linework without breakup
  • Same forgiving Arches cotton and sizing
  • Ideal for pen-and-wash and botanical illustration
  • Scans and reproduces cleanly — no texture noise

Cons

  • Washes are harder to control than on cold press
  • Water moves fast; hard edges and blooms set quickly
  • Pad format buckles more than a block under heavy water

Hot press is not a beginner's paper, and the reason is counterintuitive: smooth is harder. Cold press texture slows water down and breaks up edges naturally. Take that texture away and washes race across the sheet, edges set hard where you didn't want them, and blooms appear fast.

When it's clearly right: any time a line matters. Botanical illustration, architectural subjects, and pen-and-wash all need a surface that won't break a fine line into dots, and hot press is the only choice that delivers it.
Format note: this is a pad, not a block, so it will cockle under heavy water. Stretch it or tape it down if you plan to flood large washes — see our full watercolor paper guide for the stretching method.

The same Arches cotton and sizing on a smooth, near-plate surface. Hot press is the right choice for fine detail, ink-and-wash, and botanical illustration where cold press texture would fight the linework.

Buy hot press if you draw into your watercolor — botanical illustration, architectural subjects, pen-and-wash. The smooth surface takes a fine line without the tooth breaking it up.

What we don't like

Smooth paper is less forgiving of washes. Water moves fast across the surface, edges set hard, and blooms are harder to avoid. Most painters find hot press harder to control than cold press, not easier.

Check Arches Hot Press on Amazon →~$25 · Arches

Austin Art Insider

Free weekly guide to galleries, exhibitions & collecting in Austin.

How we
chose

This is a research-desk comparison built from published manufacturer specifications — fibre content, sizing method, weight, and surface — cross-checked against what watercolorists consistently report after long use of each sheet. Five criteria:

  • Fibre content. 100% cotton versus cellulose is the single largest determinant of how a sheet behaves under water, and it explains most of the price gap.
  • Sizing and lifting. Sizing is the gelatin or synthetic treatment that controls how fast pigment sinks in. Heavy internal sizing is what lets you lift a passage back to near-white; light sizing means the first mark is permanent.
  • Buckling under water. How much the sheet cockles when flooded, and whether the format (block versus pad) solves it for you.
  • Surface durability. Whether the sheet survives scrubbing, masking-fluid removal, and repeated reworking without pilling.
  • Cost per sheet. Compared per-sheet at a common size, since blocks and pads have very different counts.

Quick Shop

All Products at a Glance

Every product in this guide, with direct links to current prices.

1Arches Watercolor Block, 140 lb Cold Press, 9×12 inBest Overall · Arches~$41Shop on Amazon →2Fabriano Artistico Watercolor Block, Extra White, 5×7 inBest for Bright, High-Key Work · Fabriano~$19Shop on Amazon →3Strathmore 400 Series Watercolor Block, Cold Press, 9×12 inBest Value · Strathmore~$20Shop on Amazon →4Arches Aquarelle Watercolor Pad, Hot Press, 140 lb, 9×12 inBest for Detail & Botanical · Arches~$25Shop on Amazon →

Share this guide

Share

Common Questions

Frequently Asked Questions

Have art
to sell?

Austin Gallery specializes in selling inherited art, estate collections, and fine art with zero upfront fees. Get a free evaluation today.

Consign With Ust@austingallery.org